The Economic Cost Of Traffic. Clogged Up Thinking.

Our city is becoming harder and harder to get around. There are solutions to the problem, but it needs the political will to find them.

In the SCMP: Clogged-up thinking is not helping to solve traffic crisis Adobe_PDF_file_icon

20151216 Clogged-up thinkingA free parking space in Statue Square for my parent’s antiquated Austin 1300 was getting hard to find by the early 1970’s. When I had my own car in the eighties, I became an expert at legal on-street parking on Lockhart Road and off-street parking in the waste sites around Central. These had disappeared by the nineties as the police actively enforced parking discipline and designated car parks became the GOTO place.

Nowadays you can park in Central again, just like the seventies. Around lunchtime last week, stationary vehicles occupied a whole lane down Ice House Street; were stacked up on Chater Road and Edinburgh Place; all along Jackson Road (two deep); and seven were crammed into a single layby in Lower Albert Road. There is usually a driver snoozing inside, waiting to pick up a mistress from shopping, or master from work; keeping the engine running in the unlikely event of our otherwise highly visible men in blue, becoming visible.

The plan area of a Toyota Alphard – a popular parker, if perhaps one of the most disgustingly uncool vehicles ever designed – is 96 square feet. Let’s assume another 75% to allow for parking manoeuvres. The opportunity cost of casual parking by each uncool chauffeur-driven Alphard in our busy thoroughfares (taking a notional rental per month of $100 per square foot) is therefore over $200,000 per annum per car. The ultra cool Tesla Model S, also a popular obstructer, costs the taxpayer and the travelling public 15% more.

The chauffeur owners, who game the rest of society by saving $6,000 per month for a space in a legitimate car park, are ironically among the top few percent of the very wealthiest in Hong Kong. In the annals of bad behaviour, it equates to dog fouling, or leaving cigarette butts in the street.

This is only part of the cost, for according to a recent SCMP analysis, the speed of Central traffic in just the last five years has fallen by a whopping 25%. In parts of Sheung Wan it is really is quicker to walk. To remain an effective global business centre, we have to be able get around our own city.

We have a traffic crisis of the like unseen since the 1980’s. The Colonial administration took aggressive measures to deal with the impending catastrophe by ensuring strict police enforcement to keep roads free of obstructions.  Enforcement fines, a high first registration tax, and an annual vehicle examination test raised the cost of driving closer to the cost on society.

But it is also unfair to make private vehicles a rich man’s toy, as those disabled or living in isolated areas may need a car, so a cost-effective road-building programme was undertaken in the eighties to cater for the increase in population. Flyovers and underpasses seemed to appear instantly as the government reacted to bottlenecks. Once one blockage was cleared, it moved elsewhere; the widening of Repulse Bay Road led to jams around the Stubbs Road roundabout, so the Stubbs Road flyover was built and the end of Stubbs Road was widened. Eventually the choke points were minimised – for a while. Small-scale road improvements are a very inexpensive way to increase economic productivity.

The government has been spending heavily on grandiose road projects like the $200 billion bridge to Zhuhai – that would have paid for a multitude of road widening’s, flyovers and underpasses. It takes huge amounts of administrative time, long debates, and money to build a white elephant; meanwhile Stubbs Road will become all but impassible once traffic from the old Lingnan College site begins to flow.

The announcement last week of higher parking fines will make little difference. The first proposed increase since 1994 to just $480 will mean that parking ticket fine inflation will have been a measly 1.8% per year. Mere inflation would have taken a parking ticket to $525; HK house price inflation to $700.

Electronic Road Pricing was discussed and dismissed in the 1980 and 1990’s for good reason because Hong Kong’s geography does not suit such a penalty zone. It turns the heart of a city into a ghost town – better a honking Central than an oasis of quiet. Also commercial drivers will whine and get undeserved exemptions. If the government wants a blue-sky option they could fund research into driverless cars – they are coming and Hong Kong is a uniquely ideal test bed.

As always, the solutions to traffic congestion are not hard to formulate. We have the money. It just depends whether our policymakers want to take action – or perhaps it is their chauffeurs who are clogging up Central.


Richard Harris of Port Shelter ( has been in the investment industry in Asia for 39 years and occasionally presents Money Talk on RTHK.

Have your say!